recognizing fallacies

Nothing has renewed my passion for effective thinking-skill programs as much as my recent stint as a juror. Being sequestered with my fellow jurors to decide the immediate fate of an individual, I saw adults who were not only unable to discern obvious fallacies in logic, but who also put more credibility in a similar episode of a popular TV program than in actual testimony from a licensed doctor or an experienced police officer, which was scary.
Even if I were indifferent to the fate of the innocent (or criminals) in my community, knowing how to think and how to discern fallacies in logic is relevant in all areas of life. It impacts everything from the beverage I drink to who I vote for. While it is dismaying to see misleading ideas actually welcomed into a jury room, it is even more devastating to see believers unable to recognize fallacies as they share the gospel with others. These common fallacies include:
- If Jesus didn’t stay dead then it wasn’t the ultimate sacrifice.
- God loves me and anyone who loves me would never let harm happen to me. Therefore anything bad that happens to me did not come from God.
- Since so many people believe in so many different religions, there must be many different gods.
- It’s been 2,000 years; if the Bible is true then Jesus would have already returned.
But fallacies in logic don’t end at your front door. During a recent lively mother/child exchange of ideas I was reminded of many misleading statements I heard growing up, such as:
- I didn’t ask to be born, so why should I obey you?
- Maybe I did hit him, but I spent all day building that and he purposely wrecked it.
- Everyone else was doing it and I didn’t want to be the only weird one.
- If I can’t have (insert toy or game) I’ll just die.
- I don’t care if money is tight, we have always taken a vacation and I want to do so again this year.
Working through fallacies “in-house” should produce children who can refute erroneous ideas away from home. While we sell a number of thinking-skill programs, the best tool is a parent who will take the time to talk with his or her children and ask thoughtful questions which repeatedly point them to the cross and their need for sanctification. As 1 John 1:4 says, “I have no greater joy than to hear that my children are walking in the truth.”






children, your redeemer will be those programs that ensure accelerated learning and your god becomes academic success.